Skip to main content

How To Decide to Rent a Home or Buy - The Easy Way

A key piece to living a debt-free bigger life for me was to sell the bigger house and downsize my living expenses -- from the monthly entergy bill to the rent.  It took a year, but I sold my Big House with the plan to Buy a Smaller One. Lessons learned about EBay, Craigs List, Renting and Moving are some of  the more popular posts.

Selling the Pool Table via Craig's List
Creating Stability with UPS Address
First Steps in Downsizing

The equity has been sitting in a nice Capitol One savings stash, earning 4% interest until November 2009, and I had figured I was saving money renting versus owning (quite a contrarian opinion!).   But I was living in a luxury condo and paying $5,000 a year less in expenses, so there was no impetus to buy.*

Each of these free internet calculators offered me the information I needed to make that decision to rent for 18 months.  Thanks to the New York Times, Michael Blue Jay's Awesome Calculator,, JD Roth, a devil's advocate opinion from Bargaineering,'s "Not Everyone Should Own a Home!", as well as a few surprises such as the calculator on

So...why am I two weeks away from closing on a townhome with the potential of saving $3,300 per year...and why should you consider doing the same?

For a couple of very good reasons -- the extended First-time Home Buyer's Tax Credit of $6,500 and the lowest interest rates on cash savings in a lifetime. Here's an example that any non-math major can follow with their own figures to figure out what's best for you.

A Simple English Major's Comparison of Renting versus Buying:

Fill in these blanks (my data is listed as an example below each number.

Rental Data:

1)  Rental property background:  1200 square feet, 2 bedrooms, 2 bath, in great mid-town, safe location.

2) Rent $:  _____
$1100 per month for a 2 bedroom, 2 bath 1200 square foot condo in about 10 minutes from work

3) Renter's Insurance:  _____
$40 per month

4) Utilities: _____
$100 per month average for gas and electric, water and sewer included

5) Cable Television:  _____
$45 per month

6) Cable Hi Speed Internet:  _____
$40 per month

Subtotal = $1325/mo

Then Deduct:

7) Tax Deduction for Real Estate Taxes: _____

8) Tax Deduction for Mortgage Interest: _____

9) How much you are earning from your down payment/equity being in a savings account, minus taxes: ____
$56 per month     ($53,000 down payment * 1.5% interest minus 15% tax effect/12)

Renting Annual Total = $15,228

Purchase Comparison Data:
1) Purchase property background:  I'm purchasing a bigger townhouse (1,450 square feet) than the condo I'm renting so I'll get a couple of extra hundred square feet, but lose a screened in porch.  Not sure how to put that into monetary value, but

You can go to or any other mortgage table calculator to figure out mortgage principal and interest for various scenarios.  In my case, my townhome price is $136,500, loan percentage and length is 5.125% loan over 30 years, $50,000 down, and closing costs of $3,075.  That gave me the numbers for #1 starting below.

2)  Mortgage$ (Principal and Interest): __________

3) Hazard Insurance: _____
$62 per month (available from previous home owner or your insurance agent)

4) Real Estate Taxes:  _____
$100 per month estimate (estimates available from your local tax assessor)

5) Home Owner's Association: _____
$129 per month
(includes cable television)

6) Water and Sewer: _____
$60 per month

7) Maintenance Sinking Fund: _____
$200 per month, general rule of thumb.
(painting, decorating, new roof, new appliances)

8) Utilities: _____
$100 per month (same square footage as condo)

9) Cable Hi Speed Internet:  _____

Subtotal = $13,968 or ($1164 * 12)

Then Deduct: 

10)  Deduct tax savings for real estate taxes: ______
(approximateley $70 per month for me in tax savings.  Real esate taxes $100/mo and mortgage interest $398 per month in first year = $468*.15 tax bracket =  $70 approximate per month in tax savings first few years if itemizing.)

11)  Deduct any interest on cash you aren't putting into the down payment, if applicable: _____
$23 per month ($22,000 still left in savings from first home sold equity * .15/12)

Owning Total:  $11,928
($1071 * 12)

Conclusion -- Although the monthly difference doesn't seem to be large, only $1071 versus $1269, you can see on an annual level how the annual total of $3,300 is a significant savings.  In  my tax bracket of 15%, I would have to earn an extra $3700 per year to get this kind of savings! 
Do you think I made the right? decision? Are you struggling with similar decisions?  Share!

1st Time Home Buyer's Tax Credit Note - The $6,500 first time home buyers tax credit covers closing costs and miscellaneous expenses such as moving, furniture, new draperies, unexpected repairs in first year.

*(Additional costs for the bigger home included $2,500 extra per year in maintenance, $1200 per year in lawn maintenance, $1,500 per year in water/sewer /pest control and additional utility costs of $1200 per year, because I was in double the square footage.)


  1. Thanks Jeff, I appreciate the comment. Since I plan on staying in the home for at least 3 years, I believe the tax credit is going to work for me. Others who aren't sure -- probably need to be careful. Too bad that crystal ball into the future isn't always available!

  2. thanks Gloria! Your properties for rent are beautiful. Maybe I should move to Las Vegas.

  3. House is a place where you chill, relax and spend almost half of your life. So, buying a well developed and well-built dream must be a top priority. The best place to live in Pakistan is Karachi


Post a Comment

Most Popular Posts

Jackson-Hewitt Tax School

Scary thing to do -- I signed up for Jackson-Hewitt Tax School yesterday. The personable young lady who administered my registration test asked me "why do you want to come to tax school?" I told her I write a blog. People reading my blog need simple information about taxes and I sure need to understand taxes if I'm going to write a money blog. She smiled at the idea of the blog and took my $99 (it's a free course, but the books cost a pretty penny). You can go to tax school too. The time to enroll is now! H&R Block  has a tax school as well, but the last time I checked, it costs around  $250. If you do well, they will sign you up for part-time work if you are interested. I probably won't do it, since the hourly pay to begin with is pretty low. But it could be a life-saver for someone who lost their job during the recession. This is the season that tax schools do their training. You won't be able to sign up for one of these cours

The Best Juicy Frugal Tips Starting with Coffee

Maybe it's because I live in Louisiana.  This part of the country drips with warm weather, great food and drink, and a constant stream of live music.  And we share some of the same European "squeeze  the juice out of every moment" daily lifestyle habits.    Like the love of coffee.   It's a $4-6 per day habit in my house, even when I make most of it at home.  Some say cut it out of your budget, it's a waste.   I say that's ridiculous.   In fact,  I propose that you cut something else out of the budget just to keep coffee in!  Why?   1) It's good for your health (and this is from the people and research at Harvard , mon ami).  2)  It's one of the best inexpensive ways to add a frugal juiciness to every day of your life.     The Belgians love coffee so much that they serve chocolate with every cup -- free of charge.  It's a visual    If you want to immerse yourself in the Belgian way, check out this blogger's post  about the Belg

Mint Wins with the Envelopes Method

Hallelujah! has edged out Quicken with a new budgeting development in the software -- the ability to track expenses a la the Envelope method.  I'm freed from the Quicken annual subscription fee shackles ...and you could be too! I've been comparing Quicken and Mint for some time and reporting about it on this blog.  Just recently I noticed a Mint upgrade that promised to "roll over" a monthly budget category, so I tested it for the month of May, 2011.   As you may know, the Envelope budgeting method, espoused by Dave Ramsey and all manner of other financial gurus, is really pretty sweet.  What doesn't get used in one envelope (or category), can be shifted to another.  What isn't used in one month in your category (i.e., groceries), can be rolled over to the next month. In my May 2011 grocery budget, for example, I underestimated my monthly $200 alotment by $8.  (Maybe it was all those coupons I used!).   In any case, those $8 are now sitting i